In 1959, a group of wealthy outsiders set out to do the impossible: build a rival league to challenge the NFL. Along the way, Al Davis raided NFL rosters for quarterbacks, Joe Namath guaranteed a Super Bowl victory nobody believed, and NBC infamously decided to cut away from a close game to air a children’s movie. In today’s video, we’ll take a look back at the rise and fall of the American Football League.
The Foolish Club
In the 1950’s, the NFL had become increasingly popular, even inching closer to baseball as the country’s favorite pastime. But one team, the Chicago Cardinals, wasn’t getting rich off it. The Bidwill family’s team played second fiddle to the Bears in the same city, and the owners wanted out, with St. Louis as their dream destination. But there was one problem, the league wanted a payment before it would sign off on a move, and the Bidwills were short on cash, so they started listening to anyone with money to spend.
One of the men who came calling was Lamar Hunt, son and heir of millionaire oilman H. L. Hunt. He offered to buy the Cardinals and move them to his hometown of Dallas, but the talks failed. The Bidwills insisted on keeping a controlling interest, and they didn’t want to send their team to a city where an NFL franchise had already failed in 1952, with the Dallas Texans. Similar offers were made from Bud Adams, Bob Howsam, and Max Winter but they went nowhere as well.
So the frustrated suitors changed course. Hunt, Adams and Howsam asked NFL commissioner Bert Bell to add expansion teams instead. Commissioner Bell, wary of enlarging the 12-team league and risking its newfound success, said no.
On the flight home to Dallas, Hunt had a bigger idea: why not create an entirely new league? He contacted the others who had chased the Cardinals, and in March 1959 he met with Adams. Believing a regional rivalry would be critical, Hunt convinced Adams to establish a team in Houston. Howsam agreed to bring one to Denver, and Winter and his partner Bill Boyer signed on for Minneapolis–Saint Paul. With that, the league had its first four teams.
Within weeks of the July 1959 announcement of the league’s formation, Barron Hilton and Harry Wismer committed to bring teams to Los Angeles and New York. A Seattle bid collapsed when the University of Washington refused to lend the fledgling league Husky Stadium, and Buffalo balked when Hunt’s first choice of owner, Pat McGroder declined.
On August 14, 1959, the first league meeting was held in Chicago, and charter memberships went to Dallas, New York, Houston, Denver, Los Angeles and Minneapolis–Saint Paul. On August 22, at a meeting in Dallas, the league was officially named the American Football League.
The NFL’s first reaction was surprisingly, not openly hostile. Commissioner Bell even gave his public approval. But Bell died suddenly in October 1959, and individual NFL owners began a campaign to undermine the newcomers. They dangled new NFL franchises and ownership stakes in front of AFL owners. Only the Minneapolis–Saint Paul group accepted. In November, Winter announced his intent to leave, and the group joined the NFL in 1961 as the Minnesota Vikings. The NFL also reversed its stance against expansion on August 29, announcing teams for Houston and Dallas. Houston never got one, but the Dallas Cowboys began play in 1960. And the league came to terms with the Bidwills, moving the Cardinals to St. Louis and eliminating that city as an AFL market.
With all of the changes, the AFL had to rebuild on the fly. Barron Hilton demanded that Minnesota’s replacement be placed in California to cut his team’s costs and create a rivalry. Oakland was chosen, and a group led by F. Wayne Valley and real estate developer Chet Soda was formed. After a brief spell as the Oakland Señors, the Raiders officially joined the AFL on January 30, 1960.
Buffalo fell into place when Ralph Wilson, a minority owner of the NFL’s Detroit Lions, was rebuffed in Miami and instead negotiated with McGroder, earning a franchise on October 28. On November 22, a 10-man group from Boston, led by Billy Sullivan, was awarded the eighth team.
The league needed a leader and an identity. On November 30, Joe Foss, a World War II Marine fighter ace and former governor of South Dakota, was named the AFL’s first commissioner. Hunt was elected president on January 26, 1960.
Then came the first major success. The Houston Oilers signed Billy Cannon, the LSU All-American and 1959 Heisman Trophy winner, to a $100,000 contract, even though Cannon had already signed a $50,000 deal with the NFL’s Los Angeles Rams. The courts upheld the Houston contract, and with Cannon, the Oilers reached the AFL’s first three championship games, winning two.
On June 9, 1960, the league signed a five-year television contract with ABC worth about $2.125 million a year.
The AFL began regular-season play on Friday, September 9, 1960, with eight teams: the Boston Patriots, Buffalo Bills, Dallas Texans, Denver Broncos, Houston Oilers, Los Angeles Chargers, Titans of New York and Oakland Raiders. Raiders co-owner Wayne Valley dubbed the owners “The Foolish Club,” a term Hunt later used on team photographs he sent as Christmas gifts.
Once the AFL kicked off in 1960, the hard part was staying alive. Crowds were thin, the checks were bouncing, and the NFL was happy to wait for the upstarts to fold. But over the next six years, the AFL would find unexpected ways to survive, a few games that gave the league some credibility, and a growing sense that the two sides could not keep fighting each other forever.
Fighting For Survival
The Oilers became the first league champions, beating the Chargers 24–16 on January 1, 1961. But the money involved was a different story. In 1960, the NFL averaged more than 40,000 fans per game. The AFL averaged about 16,500. In a gate-driven business, low attendance meant losses. The Raiders, with a league-worst average of just 9,612, lost $500,000 in their first year and survived only after a $400,000 loan from Bills owner Ralph Wilson. Still, the AFL lost no teams.
The Raiders struggled on the field as well, winning just six games in their debut season, and winning only three times across 1961 and 1962. The Titans of New York had their own troubles. Attendance was so poor that owner Harry Wismer had fans move closer to the field to give the illusion of a fuller stadium on television. When he could no longer meet his payroll, the AFL took over the team on November 8, 1962. A few months later, it was sold to a group headed by Sonny Werblin, who renamed it the New York Jets.
The league also produced its first classic. On December 23, 1962, the Dallas Texans dethroned the two-time champion Oilers, 20–17, in a double-overtime game that was then the longest game in pro football history.
Yet winning wasn’t enough in Dallas. Hunt concluded the Texans could not profit in the same market as the Cowboys. After meetings with New Orleans, Atlanta and Miami, he announced on May 22, 1963, that the team was moving to Kansas City. Harold Roe Bartle, the Mayor of Kansas City, also nicknamed “Chief,” was instrumental in landing the team, and partly to honor him, it became the Kansas City Chiefs on May 26, 1963.
That season, the San Diego Chargers, under head coach Sid Gillman, crushed the Boston Patriots 51–10 for the AFL title. Gillman was so confident his team could beat the NFL champion Chicago Bears that he had the Chargers’ rings inscribed “World Champions.” He proposed a final game between the two champions to Pete Rozelle, who was now the NFL commissioner. However, Rozelle declined, but the idea for such a game would continue to grow stronger over the next few years.
On January 29, 1964, the AFL signed a $36 million television contract with NBC, beginning in 1965. This was a huge step forward in legitimacy for the AFL, and Pittsburgh Steelers owner Art Rooney even reportedly told Rozelle, “They don’t have to call us ‘Mister’ anymore.” In November 1964, a crowd of 61,929 packed Shea Stadium to watch the Jets and Bills.
The bidding war for players escalated in 1965. When the Jets and the NFL’s St. Louis Cardinals both drafted Alabama quarterback Joe Namath. New York convinced Namath to sign a $427,000 contract with the Jets on January 2, 1965, which included a new car. It was the most ever paid to a college player, and was later cited as one of the strongest contributing factors to the merger.
The league was growing too, in June 1965, the AFL awarded its first expansion team to Cox Broadcasting of Atlanta. But the NFL intervened, but quickly offered insurance executive Rankin Smith a franchise, which he accepted, and the Atlanta Falcons began play in the NFL in 1966. The AFL then turned to Miami, awarding its ninth franchise to Joe Robbie and entertainer Danny Thomas on August 16, and the Miami Dolphins began play in 1966.
That same year, the NFL-AFL rivalry hit its peak. On April 7, Joe Foss resigned as commissioner. His successor was Al Davis, the Raiders’ head coach and general manager, who had been instrumental in turning around that franchise. In May, Wellington Mara, owner of the NFL’s New York Giants, broke a “gentleman’s agreement” against signing another league’s players and lured kicker Pete Gogolak away from the Bills.
The AFL struck back. Davis began recruiting players already on NFL rosters, focusing on quarterbacks, and in two months persuaded seven of them to sign with the AFL. But some owners saw the escalation as harmful to both leagues. Alarmed by the spending, Hilton Hotels forced Barron Hilton to relinquish his stake in the Chargers.
The same month that Davis took over, several NFL owners, led by Cowboys general manager Tex Schramm, secretly approached Hunt and other AFL owners about a merger. Secret meetings in Dallas addressed soaring player salaries and player poaching. By the end of May, Hunt and Schramm had completed the basic groundwork, and on June 8, 1966, the merger was announced.
The two leagues would hold a common draft and play a title game between their champions. They would be fully merged by 1970, with Rozelle as commissioner of the NFL, and expansion would follow. The Raiders and Jets would pay $18 million over 20 years to the San Francisco 49ers and New York Giants. In protest, Davis resigned on July 25 rather than wait for the merger to finish, and Milt Woodard was named AFL president.
By 1967, the AFL had survived, grown and forced its way into a merger. Now it had to prove it belonged. The first tests did not go well, and the doubters were ready to say they had been right all along. But over the next three years, a cocky quarterback and one stunning upset would change how the league was seen. And even when the AFL finally disappeared, its influence continued throughout the NFL.
I just want to pause real quick to ask, if you’re enjoying this video please hit the like button and don’t forget to subscribe and become a channel member today. The link is in the description. Also, even though the AFL eventually merged with the NFL, it was successful in establishing itself as a legitimate alternative to the NFL. So do you think that a modern version of the AFL could work today? Or is the NFL simply too big and powerful to have meaningful competition? Let me know in the comments below! Ok lets get back to the video…
Changing Football Forever
The first test came on January 15, 1967, in Los Angeles, in the “AFL-NFL World Championship Game,” later known as Super Bowl I. After a close first half, the NFL’s Green Bay Packers overwhelmed the Kansas City Chiefs, 35–10. For many, the loss reinforced the notion that the AFL was inferior. Packers coach Vince Lombardi said, “I do not think they are as good as the top teams in the National Football League.”
Super Bowl II brought a similar result. The Oakland Raiders, who had easily beaten the Oilers for their first AFL title, were overmatched by the Packers, 33–14. Still, Packers tackle Henry Jordan offered a compliment, saying the AFL was “becoming much more sophisticated on offense.”
On May 24, 1967, the AFL added its tenth and final team, awarding a franchise to a Cincinnati group headed by NFL legend Paul Brown. Brown had intended to join the NFL, but agreed to the AFL when he learned his team would join the NFL after the merger. The Cincinnati Bengals began play in 1968.
In a somewhat funny and peculiar moment late in the 1968 season, NBC made a decision that would be sure to be a PR disaster today. On November 17, 1968, near the end of a Jets–Raiders game, NBC decided to cut away to show Heidi, a children’s movie. Fans had been watching the Jets lead 32–29 with just 65 seconds left in the 4th quarter when, at 7:00 p.m. Eastern, NBC switched away to air its scheduled movie. Millions of viewers along the East Coast missed Oakland’s two late touchdowns, with the Raiders coming back to beat the Jets 43-32.
Enraged fans jammed NBC’s switchboards and even flooded emergency police lines with complaints. The backlash was so severe that the NFL changed its contracts to require networks to broadcast games in their entirety. Although there was no social media at that time for something like that to blow up on, the uproar from upset fans was loud anyways, and it proved how much people cared about the AFL.
Then, on January 12, 1969, the perception changed forever. The AFL champion New York Jets shocked the heavily favored Baltimore Colts in Super Bowl III. The Colts, favored by as many as 18 points, had gone 13–1 and won the NFL title with a 34–0 win over the Cleveland Browns, led by a defense that allowed a record-low 144 points. The Jets had allowed 280 points, the most of any division winner in either league, and had narrowly beaten the Raiders 27–23 for the AFL title.
Namath, angry at being told New York had no chance, had responded to a heckler in Miami three days before the game: “We’re going to win Sunday, I guarantee it!” He made good, and the Jets held the Colts scoreless until late in the fourth quarter. The Jets won, 16–7, in one of the greatest upsets in American sports history. The AFL had achieved parity, and the merger was legitimized. A year later, in Super Bowl IV, the AFL champion Chiefs upset the Minnesota Vikings, 23–7, in the last title game between the two leagues.
The last game in AFL history was the AFL All-Star Game, held in Houston’s Astrodome on January 17, 1970. The Western All-Stars, led by Chargers quarterback John Hadl, beat the East 26–3, and rookie O. J. Simpson carried the ball for the last play in AFL history. On February 1, 1970, the AFL ceased to exist when the NFL granted 10 new franchises and issued a new constitution.
The merged league was organized into two conferences. All ten AFL teams made up the bulk of the new American Football Conference, but three NFL teams moved over to even the numbers. Cleveland Browns owner Art Modell, motivated by the prospect of a rivalry with the Bengals and by personal animosity toward Paul Brown, quickly volunteered, and helped persuade the Pittsburgh Steelers and Baltimore Colts to follow. Each team received $3 million.
To this day, the AFL’s legacy remains enormous. It is the only professional football league to successfully compete against the NFL. All ten AFL franchises and their statistics became part of the NFL, and none ever folded. Every other rival, from the AAFC, WFL, and the original USFL and the XFL, all eventually folded.
The NFL adopted many AFL innovations. These included names on player jerseys and using the stadium scoreboard clock for official game time. The AFL played a 14-game schedule from 1960, and the NFL followed in 1961. The AFL introduced the two-point conversion 34 years before the NFL did in 1994. Its flashier style, with long “bombs” thrown by quarterbacks such as Hadl, Daryle Lamonica and Len Dawson, and its colorful uniforms, made today’s game more like the AFL than the old-line NFL.
The AFL also reshaped the map. It put teams in major cities without NFL franchises, bringing pro football to California, New York, Colorado and later Florida, and returning it to the greater Boston area.
Kevin Sherrington of The Dallas Morning News has argued that the merger saved the Steelers “from stinking.” Before it, Pittsburgh had just eight winning seasons and one playoff appearance from 1933 through 1969. The $3 million indemnity helped them rebuild, drafting Terry Bradshaw and Joe Greene, and they won four Super Bowls in the 1970s.
Perhaps the AFL’s greatest social legacy was its willingness to offer opportunities to Black players. While many NFL teams were still slow to recruit Black talent, the AFL actively scouted players from small, predominantly Black colleges.That led not only to an explosion of talent on the field but, eventually, to black coaches and executives entering scouting, coordinating and head coaching jobs long after the league had merged itself out of existence.
In 2009, the league’s 50th anniversary was celebrated all season, beginning with the Hall of Fame Game between two original AFL franchises, the Bills and the Tennessee Titans, who were the former Houston Oilers. AFL “Legacy” gear made up 20 to 30 percent of the NFL’s annual $3 billion in merchandise income.
Although every member of the original Foolish Club has since passed away, the Tennessee Titans and Kansas City Chiefs to this day remain owned by the descendants of Bud Adams and Lamar Hunt. What began as a response to a rejected offer became the league that remade professional football.
If you enjoyed this video, be sure to check out my video on the World Football League, founded by the same man who helped start the WHA, Gary Davidson. I explore how the WFL tried to challenge the NFL, lured away star players, and ultimately collapsed under financial problems and franchise chaos after just two seasons. As always, please like and subscribe, and thanks for watching!

Leave a Reply